Scotscraig Golf Club
Fife, ScotlandOverview
The basis for C.B MacDonald & Seth Raynor's Knoll template hole is probably the fourth.
For most, they will drive past the course on their way from St Andrews to Carnoustie blissfully unaware of what they've missed.
The golf course could be described as a hybrid links-heathland and is the 13th oldest golf club in the world! The oldest medal in golf, The Gold Medal, is still played for at the club - now for over 200 years!
Justin Rose is an honorary member. He almost qualified for an Open here at 14 years of age.
Golf Course Review
Scotscraig Golf Club in the seaside town of Tayport, Fife is located just 10 miles from the famous Old Course at St Andrew's. It was founded by members of what would become the R&A. The connection is still strong with Scotscraig Golf Club used for Open Qualifying when The Open is at St Andrews.
Scotscraig Golf Club Architectural History
Founded in 1817, Scotscraig Golf Club would be extended to 9 holes in 1893. The course was then extended to 18 holes in 1904. In 1923, James Braid would make the course more or less what it is today.
The Knoll Template Hole
It was James Braid who would create the 4th hole known as Westward Ho at Scotscraig Golf Club. The green was located atop a small hill or 'knoll' and the rest is history.
It may seem absurd that placing a green atop a raised done would be enough to cause CB Macdonald along with Seth Raynor popularised the concept in America. But remember, in context, most green sites would have been located in depressions and hollows to aid with rainfall collection. A deviation from the norm would have been more pronounced then than now.
Similar to the Knoll is the Volcano - essentially a Knoll on steroids and typically a par 3. These are found on many of Donald Ross' designs but the original may well have been James Braid's at Gleneagles Kings! Of course, there is conjecture and speculation as anyone who knows of Royal Dornoch and its greens could see where Ross may have found his inspiration.
Whether Westward Ho is the original Knoll or not, this dogleg par 4 is worth the journey a few minutes from St Andrews to see!
Scotscraig Golf Club Photography
Purchase Kevin Murray's photography of Scotscraig Golf Club.
Evalu18 Featured Architect: James Braid
James Braid moved very little earth due to technological constraints. Minimal artificial features are present. Putting greens must be well guarded, often by dykes, directly in front of greens. Green size is governed by the length of the approach. Alternative tees are provided to allow play in all conditions. Bunkering...
View ProfileAt a glance
Architects
Facilities
Collections
This course features in these collections. Click an icon to view the entire set.
Evalu18 Featured Architect: James Braid
James Braid moved very little earth due to technological constraints. Minimal artificial features are present. Putting greens must be well guarded, often by dykes, directly in front of greens. Green size is governed by the length of the approach. Alternative tees are provided to allow play in all conditions. Bunkering...
View Profile
My Bucket List
Please login or register to add this content to a list.
Location
Evalu18 Journal
Try these featured posts from our Journal.
-
Golf Minimalism & The Humble Sunday Bag
From equipment decadence to minimalism. The journey to <14 and a Sunday Bag.
-
Golf Art
Refined, high-quality, modern golf art prints in small batches.
-
What is Golf Course Architecture?
What is Golf Course Architecture? The answer may just be as simple and as profound as you want to make it!
Peter Sherwood Evalu18 
Joe McDonnell 
Evalu18 
Kevin Murray JCB Golf & Country Club
