Holes of Merit:2, 3, 6, 7, 9, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17
NCG Rank:11/100 in GB&I
Golf.com Rank:37/100 in the World
Tom Doak recommends paying special attention to the green contouring and routing at North Berwick Golf Club.
Both Tom Dunn and David Strath were employed as greenkeepers.
Golf on Sunday's was first allowed in 1957!
The Original 'Template' Holes
Pit, Perfection, Redan and Gate are perhaps the most celebrated stretch of holes in golf to the architectural student.
There is no more famous template in golf than the Redan. But, what is it? A redan is a protruding feature of a fortification. Usually V-shaped, it is a salient built of earth or other building material and laid out pointed to the expected angle of attack. An officer serving in the British army stormed a Russian redan during the Crimean War in Sevastopol. Upon his return, he described the 15th hole as a redan in nature. As at North Berwick Golf Club, the point of the V points away from the angle of attack on most redans.
Redan provided Alister MacKenzie with the inspiration for the 6th at Augusta National. It also was one of Herbert Fowler's four ideal golf holes as chosen in 1913, although his Redan had water at the head of the green. CB Macdonald recreated Redans frequently but it is his design at National Golf Links of America which is considered by many to be better even than the original.
Independent Reviews of North Berwick
Sean Arble's tour of the West Links can be found here
Jaeger Kovich contributed an analysis of the 13th hole on The Fried Egg
North Berwick GC Videos
Watch No Laying Up's visit to North Berwick here
Golf Course Review
North Berwick Golf Club West Links is a celebrated links golf course on the East Lothian coastline of Scotland. Given the plethora of choice of world-class golf on offer, North Berwick is perpetually cited amongst the top three in the vicinity. The other two? Muirfield and Gullane.
A Study in Contrasts
Despite keeping a close company on bucket lists, rakings and geographically, North Berwick and The Honourable Company are a study in contrasts. North Berwick is a proper seaside links, Muirfield is hilltop. North Berwick, stretched to its max, plays less than 7000 yards, Muirfield confidently measures 7245 yards. North Berwick begins and ends in town, Muirfield is sat back from the public road and accessed by a long private drive. North Berwick is full of quirk and eccentricity while Muirfield is classically elegant. North Berwick is bisected by dykes and walls while Muirfield is surrounded by one. The contrasts are seemingly endless but perfectly illustrate that great golf doesn't fit a mould.
A History of Golf at North Berwick
The first reference to golf at North Berwick is in 1605 but it would be 227 years before a club was formerly organised! 28 members established The North Berwick Golf Club on June 1, 1832, and played over a 6 hole course which ended at March Dyke. This makes North Berwick the thirteenth oldest golf course in the world.
In 1849, Old Tom Morris and Allan Robertson take on Wille Dunn and Tom Dunn on a 7 hole course. In 1868, land was donated which allowed one of the weak holes to be dropped and three new holes to be added, one of which is the Redan. The course was now comprised of 9 holes.
In 1877, additional land is acquired which allows the links to extend to 18 holes. Criticism soon follows as 7 of the holes measure less than 200 yards and the course just 4841 yards! Ben Sayers would extend the course in 1895 to just over 6000 yards and is the backbone of the course played today. It is in 1895 that Hole 14, Perfection, is created.
The 1st and 18th have more than a passing resemblance to the Old Course at St Andrews. The tendency for many would be to route holes exclusively on the waters edge then return inland or vice-versa. Here, the first three holes begin seaside before crossing inland for the next six. Holes 10 through 14 are again along the beach with the closing stretch of four holes being inland. The beach is in play on no less than seven holes and out of bounds on another seven holes.
Golf Course Photography
Purchase photography of this course here.
This course features in these collections. Click an icon to view the entire set.
Everything you need to know before you go!
Address:East Lothian, EH39 4BB, Scotland
Everything you need to know before you go!